Fall for Dance 2026: Program 4 Review

Oct 2, 2026 · 

Three years ago I flew to New York for Fall for Dance at New York City Center, just as a big transition in my life was beginning. That trip confirmed something I had known for a long time. On Program 4 of the 2023 festival, the Limón Dance Company danced a suite from José Limón’s A Choreographic Offering, Birmingham Royal Ballet gave the US premiere of Interlinked by my friend and collaborator Juliano Nunes, and Ephrat Asherie and Michelle Dorrance premiered The Center Will Not Hold.

I left the theater electrified, mostly by what Birmingham Royal Ballet did with Juliano’s choreography and by the tap of Ephrat and Michelle. It was a mesmerizing night, and it planted the curiosity to come back.

Returning to places and events and giving them new meaning is one of the things I do best. So I did what I have been doing: I bought tickets the day they went on sale, August 30, took an early flight to New York on Thursday, and followed what is becoming my New York routine. Coffee and a book in Central Park, a museum or a corner of the city I had not explored yet, and a show at night. Next time I want to add the used bookshops.

Fittingly, I landed on Program 4 again: San Francisco Ballet, Stuttgart Ballet star Friedemann Vogel, and Gauthier Dance, also from Stuttgart, on October 1. The festival’s 23rd edition remains one of the most generous invitations in American dance.

I love New York City Center as much as I love the Met. It is charming and full of character, and that atmosphere reaches both the people watching and the people dancing.

The building began as the Shriners’ neo-Moorish Mecca Temple in the early 1920s, and Mayor La Guardia reopened it in 1943 as Manhattan’s first performing arts center for ordinary New Yorkers. It was also the first home of Balanchine’s New York City Ballet before the company moved to Lincoln Center in the 1960s. For someone who grew up in that lineage, sitting under that dome means something.

What I value most is the proximity. At City Center I feel close to the dancers. At the Met, even from a good seat, I usually feel far from them.

Before the dancing, a word about leadership, because the San Francisco Ballet that came to City Center is clearly Tamara Rojo’s company now. Since she succeeded Helgi Tomasson, she has run it less like a keeper of repertoire and more like an impresario.

  • Bold commissions. Mere Mortals (2024), Aszure Barton’s full-length ballet on the Pandora myth and artificial intelligence, was the first full-length work the company ever commissioned from a woman, and it drew crowds of first-time ticket buyers (NPR).
  • A transformational gift. That production helped inspire an anonymous $60 million gift, the largest in the company’s history, with $50 million dedicated to creating new work (SF Classical Voice).
  • A new kind of evening. Post-show DJ parties and a lobby opened up to local cultural groups and artists.
  • Touring again. Edinburgh, Sadler’s Wells and Jacob’s Pillow (its first visit in 70 years) this year, and now Fall for Dance, where Faun had its company premiere before reaching San Francisco in April (SF Ballet).

It has not all been smooth. There was a hard contract negotiation with the dancers’ union, turnover in the executive office, and a smaller roster. Still, it is another example of powerful leadership in our industry: a director who treats new work as an investment rather than a risk, and makes sure the audience feels it.

San Francisco Ballet opened with the company premiere of Sidi Larbi Cherkaoui’s Faun. The Belgian choreographer, now director of the Ballet du Grand Théâtre de Genève, made it in 2009 for Sadler’s Wells’ centenary celebration of the Ballets Russes, as a reimagining of Nijinsky’s 1912 L’Après-midi d’un faune (Eastman).

The score is Debussy’s Prélude à l’après-midi d’un faune, deliberately interrupted by new music from British composer Nitin Sawhney, so the sound slides from one century and culture into another. Costumes are by fashion designer Hussein Chalayan. The music is beautiful, and it carried the evening’s opening minutes.

Wei Wang began alone, in shorts, his body almost entirely exposed, with minimal movement that grew into intricate contemporary phrases. Nikisha Fogo joined him, and the aesthetics of both were marvelous. Her solo showed the extremes of her classical training: transitions through full turnout that seemed to pour into the next movement. Even in the pas de deux I kept finding interesting poses and shapes.

And yet I did not enjoy it as much as I would have with contemporary-trained dancers. During theory classes at the Escola de Dança Alice Arja in Rio, I once asked my dance history teacher whether simply walking on and off stage, without a single step, would still count as contemporary dance. The answer was yes. “Contemporary” has no limit on its spectrum; it includes everything new, which is why neoclassical ballets can be called contemporary too. “Modern dance,” to me, has a far more defined meaning.

That is the problem with putting high-level classical dancers into a work like this. Contemporary dancers chase quality of movement. They are not concerned with turnout, hyper-pointed feet or a held upper body, the signatures that make a classical dancer recognizable. It is telling that Cherkaoui built Faun around James O’Hara, a contemporary dancer. Fogo and Wang delivered beautiful lines, but not the weight and release that a dancer formed in that language brings.

San Francisco Ballet is, in my view, a mixed-repertoire company, and I respect the ambition. I was simply expecting a bit more.

I’ll admit it: I came more for Friedemann Vogel than for San Francisco Ballet. The Stuttgart Ballet principal has always impressed me, with a technique and freedom of movement that seem impossible for someone of his height.

ECHO:SOG was a world premiere he co-choreographed with Thomas Lempertz, a former Stuttgart Ballet soloist turned visual artist and designer who has been his creative partner since their 2021 solo Not in my hands (Spoleto Festival). The music was Busoni’s piano transcription of the Chaconne from Bach’s Violin Partita No. 2 in D minor, played live (BroadwayWorld).

The beginning was powerful. Vogel entered from the wings pushing a wheeled platform carrying a grand piano with the pianist already seated at it. It was a dramatic image, and for a moment it had me on the edge of my seat.

Once the solo turned to dancing, the picture changed. It felt made for New York and with New York in mind: the piano on stage, a costume that reminded me of Balanchine’s Who Cares?, and many jazzy, very New York steps. But for roughly half the solo the choreography seemed to sit off the music. The Chaconne is one of the most architectural pieces ever written, variation after variation over a repeating bass, and loose, jazzy phrases floated on top of it rather than living inside it.

Much of it looked improvised, as if the decision had been to keep things easy. New York audiences who know the art form deserve more care in what is brought to them. I was not alone: the woman next to me, a patron who has held subscriptions for years and attends ballet, opera and more, was not happy either, and neither were several people I spoke with at intermission. About San Francisco Ballet, I heard mixed opinions.

I still want to see Vogel at his best. Next time, I will go to Germany to watch him at home, in a role chosen for him rather than one he made for himself.

The evening closed with the US premiere of Hofesh Shechter’s Any way the wind blows, danced by Gauthier Dance, the Stuttgart contemporary company founded by former Stuttgart Ballet dancer Eric Gauthier. Shechter, the company’s artist in residence since 2021, made it this summer for a double bill called Luck/Unluck. He took “unluck” as his theme, while the “luck” half went to Aszure Barton, the same choreographer behind San Francisco Ballet’s Mere Mortals (Seeing Dance). Shechter also composed the score and designed the costumes: eleven dancers, each in different street clothes.

This was a contemporary piece danced by contemporary dancers, and it showed. It was exciting, with real quality of movement and all the energy and power you hope for from a performance. The lighting effects did a lot of work. They kept a long piece from becoming monotonous and built a sense of curiosity about what it all meant.

The moments I remember most were when the whole group moved in unison while one dancer did something entirely their own. It reminded me of the pace of New York. Take the subway and you will see dozens of people repeating the same motion, and there is always someone doing their own thing. Being original, I would say.

After Faun, it was also the clearest argument of the night: contemporary work comes fully alive in bodies trained for it.

Overall, I enjoyed the night. The performing arts are culture, and I will always support any form of art whenever I can.

But I am leaving with a lesson. Next time, I will look first at what is being performed, not just at the names on the bill. Great dancers in the wrong material, or in material made in a hurry, are still great dancers, but the evening belongs to the work.

There is a whole ballet season still ahead of me, and I am looking forward to every performance of it.